Zscaler 블로그

Zscaler 블로그의 최신 업데이트를 이메일로 받아보세요

CXO Insights

What has TikTok really taught us?

image
KYLE FIEHLER
January 17, 2023 - 5 분 소요
>What has TikTok really taught us?

Long-simmering rhetoric about U.S. lawmakers’ response to China-based TikTok is heating up. Scores of U.S. states have taken measures to restrict the app’s use by government employees. A Senate bill passed last month would ban the social media app from operating in the U.S. entirely. One Republican lawmaker has floated the idea of Bytedance selling TikTok to a U.S. company as a means of avoiding an outright ban.

Polarizing conversations elicit supporters of two extremes: TikTok is merely a platform for sharing, engaging, even educational, viral content, where its creators can earn money, connect, and interact. Or, it’s a thinly-veiled vehicle the Chinese government uses to peddle influence and mine data from foreign users. 

A strand running through the murky middle of these polar stances holds that, while it probably does harvest all sorts of data from its users, it's not that different from U.S.-based social media apps.

The hit video-sharing platform, owned by the Shanghai-based firm Bytedance, has risen to become the most downloaded app in the world. In 2022, it became only the fifth app ever to cross the 3.5 billion download threshold, famously garnering more traffic even than Google. 

Readers may remember when former President Donald Trump attempted to ban the app in the U.S. before his successor opted for a more conciliatory approach. The Biden administration has used the app to further its objectives and engaged in negotiations about privacy concerns with Bytedance. But calls to ban the app for fear of its power are growing louder – and more bipartisan.

Haven’t we seen this movie before?

Remember FaceApp? The app that used artificial intelligence to “age” its users reached peak popularity in 2019 when it shot to the top of Apple and Google’s app stores. 

Soon, journalists and privacy advocates began raising concerns about the app’s Russian origins and the vague legal language of its privacy policy. Before long, the FBI was calling it a “potential counterintelligence threat.” According to the agency, the Russian government was legally allowed to snoop on all communications or Russian servers on Russian networks without involving ISPs. 

Presumably, this meant that the likenesses and other data belonging to the app’s (self-reported) 500+ million users could be harvested by the Russian government for whatever purpose it deemed expedient. 

TikTok’s runaway popularity has caused similar concerns, albeit on a much larger scale. A 2022 report suggested that Chinese engineers have access to data belonging to U.S. users – something the company repeatedly denied. 

TikTok had made strides to win back public trust. The company teamed up with Texas-based software giant Oracle to better safeguard U.S. user data (or did it?). It disputed its “high-risk” designation made by the U.S. House of Representatives' Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) due to excessive permissions and lack of data gathering transparency.

Those efforts came crashing down in late December when Forbes revealed that TikTok admitted to spying on several of its journalists covering the social media company. This contributed to the Senate’s passing of what would be the government’s harshest pushback against TikTok to date – a ban from operating in the U.S. It’s unclear whether the House will hold a vote on the bill.

Equal opportunity influence ops?

Apps like FaceApp and TikTok raise broader questions about the faith we put in privacy regulations for software developed in authoritarian or authoritarian-leaning countries. Can they ever be trusted not to use consumer software products for spying (like location tracking, in the case of the Forbes journalists)? What about hardware or even infrastructure? 

In terms of data gathering, are U.S.-based apps all that different? How about in terms of content manipulation and influence-wielding? 

image

As the researcher Marcus Hutchins suggests, these concerns may be overblown or misplaced when focused on the abuse of users’ data. We live in an era of relentless data breaches, and much of our personal information already proliferates across the dark web.

Maybe, instead of well-documented and comparatively well-regulated data privacy rules, we should be more concerned about the influence these platforms wield. If that’s the case, TikTok may not be all that different from U.S.-run campaigns.

Last summer, researchers from Stanford and the social media analytics firm Graphika released a report detailing how Twitter and Facebook (parent company Meta) removed several overlapping accounts, believing them to be a part of a coordinated, pro-U.S. influence campaign. 

According to the report, social media activity was focused on Iran, Afghanistan, and Arabic-speaking Middle Eastern countries, in some cases publishing apps from U.S. and government-affiliated sites like Voice of America and Radio Free Europe.

"We believe this activity represents the most extensive case of covert pro-Western influence operations on social media to be reviewed and analyzed by open-source researchers to date," the researchers wrote.

Twitter alone said it scrubbed its site of nearly 300,000 tweets from almost 150 accounts.

Influence, not information, is the real weapon 

Leaving aside questions about data and privacy, how might influence tactics be used if relationships between the U.S. and China were to sour further, over Taiwan or the South China Sea, for example? Many experts, like former Crowdstrike CTO Dmitri Alperovitch, believe this scenario is possible and likely. It's easy to see how any number of geopolitical developments – whether currently on our collective radar or not – could cause information to be abused to further national aims. 

It’s unlikely these influences would cut both ways equally. A core function of China’s Great Firewall is “preserving China's ideologies from unwanted foreign influences.” Even China’s domestic version of TikTok, Douyin, serves up educational content and features a time limit for users under 14. America’s comparatively open society has no similar filter. The character of the content created by Western influencers is decidedly different. 

The Senate's bill would also ban apps originating from Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba, and Venezuela – our version of a cyber border wall. Such a move seems misguided. After all, when Russia chose to conduct one of its most concerted efforts to influence U.S. internal affairs in 2016, its weapons of choice were our own social media giants.

While we may be resigned to having our stolen data bought and sold on the dark web, having our thinking manipulated by third parties, foreign or domestic, is worth resisting. 

form submtited
읽어주셔서 감사합니다

면책 조항: 이 블로그 게시물은 정보 제공만을 목적으로 Zscaler에서 작성하였으며, 정확성, 완전성 또는 신뢰성에 대한 어떠한 보증도 없이 "있는 그대로" 제공됩니다. Zscaler는 제공된 정보를 기반으로 수행된 조치나 오류 또는 누락에 대해 어떠한 책임도 지지 않습니다. 이 블로그 게시물에 링크된 제3자 웹사이트나 리소스는 편의를 위해서만 제공되며, Zscaler는 해당 웹사이트의 콘텐츠나 관행에 대해 책임을 지지 않습니다. 모든 콘텐츠는 예고 없이 변경될 수 있습니다. 이 블로그에 접속함으로써 귀하는 본 약관에 동의하며 귀하의 필요에 따라 정보를 확인하고 사용할 전적인 책임이 귀하에게 있음을 인정합니다.

Zscaler 블로그의 최신 업데이트를 이메일로 받아보세요

양식을 제출함으로써 귀하는 당사의 개인정보 보호정책에 동의하는 것입니다.